About Kristy and Jesse - Australian Lifestyle Blog Long Distance Relationship Advice Success Story Healthy Gluten Free Recipe Blog Australian Lifestyle Blog Healthy Living | Sydney Travel Blog Freelance Recipe Development Services Sydney Australia Gluten Free Coeliac Travel Reviews and Recommendations
Tell us what you would like to see on Southern In Law with our reader request box!

Saturday, April 6, 2013

Recipe: Healthier Cookie Cake

Healthier Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake Recipe - Birthday Cake

If you're following Southern In-Law on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram - you would have seen that we had a cookie cake for Jesse's birthday on Wednesday!

I asked Jesse again and again what kind of cake or dessert he wanted for his birthday and he kept saying nothing. Well... you have to know that's not going to happen!

Jesse is always asking me for cookies and I made a batch when he got home which he said was perfect - so I decided a Cookie Cake would be the perfect cake to celebrate with.

Healthy Cookie Cake Recipe Gluten Free Low Fat Cookie Cake Recipe

You all know that I love making everyones' favourite dishes better for you - so of course I had to make this cookie cake healthier too!

Now, on the interwebs, you'll find plenty of healthier cookie recipes made with beans or funky flours - but not here on Southern In-Law! When I make a recipe healthier, I want to do it using ingredients you already have at home - and I want to make it taste even better than the original - not just like a healthy replacement. 

This cookie cake uses butter - but only a very small amount! As a receive emails all the time asking if you can use butter substitutes and margarines in my recipes, I tested this out too and I can tell you that it works perfectly in this cookie cake. 

Whilst I made a regular version for my family, I also whipped up a gluten free version for myself which worked perfectly - so this is a cake that can be anyone's birthday treat!

But onto the recipe! 

Low Fat Cookie Cake Recipe - Healthier Birthday Cakes

Healthier Cookie Cake Recipe - makes one 8" cookie cake  
Low fat, can be gluten free 
1 1/4 cups plain flour/gluten free flour
1 tsp baking soda
A pinch of salt 
4 tbsp butter or butter substitute (see note*) 
1/2 cup brown sugar, lightly packed 
1 egg
2 tsp vanilla extract
~1/2 cup chocolate chips (or mix ins of your choice)

Grease and line a 6-8" cake tin, set aside.
Cream your butter and sugar until light and fluffy.
Add in your egg and vanilla, mixing until combined. 
Gradually mix in your flour, baking soda and salt - mixing on a low speed until combined.
Mix in your chocolate chips until evenly dispersed throughout the dough.
Pour the cookie dough into the prepared cake tin, spreading out as best as you can (it will look quite thin, but it rises alot!)
Cover your tin and chill in the fridge for about 15-20 minutes (I actually left my dough in the fridge for a few hours, taking it out 10 minutes before baking)
Preheat your oven to 180°C/350°F
Place your cake tin into the oven, baking the cookie cake for about 30-45 minutes or until golden and cooked through**. 
Once cooked, leave your cookie cake to cool before removing from the tin. 

*Feel free to use margarine or non-dairy spreads as they work perfectly fine in this recipe. I used Devondale Extra Light Spread as it's what we had in the house and it clearly worked fine! (even though it says not to bake with it - I don't listen to instructions :P)
**If your cookie cake begins to brown too much, place some foil over the top of the tin and continue cooking.  

So tell me, what's your birthday cake of choice? 

I'm a chocolate girl (as if you didn't already know that) but I also love Carrot Cake and Banana Cake - so it's always a tough decision as to what I want for my birthday! Last year it was my Healthy Chocolate Brownies which are always a winner with everyone!

Don't worry that Google Reader is closing,  follow Southern In-Law on FacebookTwitterInstagramPinterestBloglovin and Feedly.  You can alsovote and nominate Southern In-Law for some upcoming blog awards!


  1. Oh my that looks soo good! Then again everything you whip up looks amazing :)

    1. Awh, thank you Marcia - you're so sweet! Jesse decided this cookie cake was so good, he never wants anything else for his birthday, haha.

  2. You'd have to choose carrot cake because banana cake is too 'everyday' haha. I loved ice-cream cakes or caramel mud cake from the cheesecake shop!
    Ps. This looks delish!

    1. Haha but it's so good!!! I can't pass up banana cake with cream cheese frosting ;P

      Loved? That should be love, girl! Calories and bad food don't count on birthdays ;P

    2. Oh my goodness, where has this cookie cake been all my life? :D
      I totally agree with your recipe makeover philosophy - it has to be use easy ingredients and it has to taste even better than the original. This cookie cake looks like a fantastic example of both these requirements.

    3. Haha, the only thing better than cookies is a cookie cake, I say!

  3. Looks delicious :) My favorite is Funfetti/confetti cake...but I am a big carrot cake fan too!

    1. Thanks Merry! It was delicious. I've never had a funfetti cake - but as a lover of sprinkles, I'm sure it'd be good!

  4. It looks delicious! I love how you made it healthier =) I'm always trying to find healthier recipes for desserts I love to eat. Thanks for sharing. I hope jesse enjoyed it. =)

    1. Oh he definitely did enjoy it! He won't let me make anything else from now on ;P

  5. I LOVE Giant Cookies & love how fluffy this one looks, so delicious - I will let you know what my other 1/2 thinks after his birthday!

  6. Cake did not come out well. Very dry and barely rose. You need to replace extra the butter that was taken out of the recipe with something to keep the cookie moist...maybe Greek yogurt, dates, banana, or avocado would work.

    1. Oh really?! I've made it three times and it's worked perfectly!

      What ingredients did you use? Gluten free or regular flours?

  7. Made it last night, all gone in one day. My kids loved it. It rose great, very yummy :)

  8. You can become a reseller for an existing hosting company.

    Doing so will help ensure you still have your site, in the event something
    happens. A good web hosting company will provide
    customer service that will help solve your problems.

    Stop by my blog post - HostInfuser


There is nothing better than reading your comments on our posts! Let us know what you think of this post!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...